Go to www.hooktheory.com

Why can't we b9 or #9 and add13 at the same time

No reason to me to have this restriction

1 Like

“add” means you add something to the triad and don’t add anything else. “Cadd9” means: Play c-e-g and add d, but don’t use the 7 (or anything else). So “Cadd13” means: Play c-e-g and add a, but nothing else.

(In fact you wouldn’t use this, because without having a 7 in the chord you wouldn’t use 13 but 6. So if you really want to have c-e-g-a and nothing else you could use Cadd6 – but I haven’t seen this in any context.)

So using the “add” bans other additions to the triad. Cb9/add13 would be a contradiction in terms.

so how would we notate a chord with both a b9 and a 13

i’m specifically trying to do a Ab7(b9)(13)- how do you do that -without- adding an 11 also

It seems to me like this is possible by selecting the ‘type’ of chord as 13 and then adding the b/# 9 with the tick boxes in the chord properties menu. To my understanding of harmony, a 13 implies a flat seventh so it’s not necessary to write out and state a 13 as an added note by your reasoning, and as peter said ‘add#’ are reserved for triads.