Chord voicing bugs

Any seventh chord sus2 in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any seventh chord sus4 in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any seventh chord sus2sus4 in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any seventh chord sus2sus4 in 2nd inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any seventh chord sus2sus4 in 3rd inversion is voiced without the seventh
Any sus2sus4 chord in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any sus2sus4 chord in 2nd inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any sus2(add6) chord in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any sus2(add11) chord in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any sus4(add6) chord in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth
Any sus4(add9) chord in 1st inversion is voiced without the fifth

1 Like

Thanks @Vaz123, sorry we missed this

@Ryan not fixed as of 2.16.0

@Ryan not fixed as of 2.16.1

hey @Vaz123, it’s on our list of known issues. We’ll get to it pretty soon after we finish a couple of other bug fixes. Appreciate the detailed report, it really helps us solve these issues quickly

@chris @dave @Ryan in A Thousand Years by Christina Perri, this bug still isn’t fixed, we still don’t have multiple sync markers, you still haven’t replied to literally any post and @HertzDevil still hasn’t replied to my private messages

@chris @Ryan @dave can you fix this now

This will be addressed in the next minor update to Hookpad. Some of these were bugs, such as 7sus2 and 7sus4 chords in inversions, but others are by design, at least for the 3-note RH voicings (such as the default harmony piano)

For chords that have 5 notes, the 5th is the first chord tone that will be omitted. After the 5th, for 11th chords the 3rd will be omitted, and for 13th chords, the 9th and 11th will be omitted.

Full voicing instruments should have all chord tones included.

Edit: these changes were implemented in v2.18.6